26.4.07

The bottomline?

“Please spare me that humiliation.”

The moment I read those words, I felt a jab of something unrecognisable.

I do not humiliate people. To me this is the worst form of abuse and I’d rather walk away than do so. It is true that what one writes can be read in several ways…it is also true that I do use life and events or they use me to collate my thoughts into some sort of expression. At least I do not use a third person as a catalyst.

This really bothers me. Am I supposed to get upset enough to respond? Then what is the value of such a response and what is the value of the stimulus if it seeks to reduce everything?

If silence bothers me, I am upfront about it and say, “You owe me a reply.” I do not think I would use anyone else as a ruse.

I should be the one feeling humiliated. But I won’t. I understand that reading people’s thoughts is a dicey business. I have never believed in stratifying things…I cannot build dams. I probably cannot even build bridges. Yet, I know that no one has ever drowned with me. I would not want that, too.

At the bottom of the ocean I am alone. It isn’t so bad having sea-weeds as anchors.

“Main samandar ki tarah khamosh baithoon muntazir
Tu chaley kohsaar se misl aab-joo mere liye”

6 comments:

Nauman said...

Kion kay is article ka matlab meri naaqis samajh say bahir hai, is liye aik sher arz hai:

Gar Khamoshi say faida ikhfa-a-haal hai
Khush hoon kay meri baat samajhna mahal hai

circle said...

blog
(I do not humiliate people. To me this is the worst form of abuse and I’d rather walk away than do so.)...

I wish everyone could be like FV!

But,people hummiliate people for no reasons...

FV said...

Circle:

Why don't you want to 'shair' me? :-)

No, everyone should not be like me...

Nauman said...

I am not really sure in what way I've annoyed you. In fact I find your writings quite interesting. But anyway people have their own sensibilities and sensitivities. And a person should avoid places where s/he is not welcome. Ciao.

FV said...

Nauman:

To say I am reeling by this sudden outburst is an understatement. I saw two couplets and when it came to replying I merely punned on the word 'shair'(share). It was honestly meant in good humour, and if at all I expected a response I imagined it would be a retort in the same vein.

You have not annoyed me, but do not even think you or anyone is not welcome here. However, whether to avoid this place or not is your decision. If you do look in here at all I hope you read this...I am sorry if the 'thing' backfired.

Best to you...

The following shair by Zafar is what I have been thinking about for hours. Please do not see added meaning in it:

"khulata nahin hai haal kisi par kahe bagair
par dil ki jaan lete hain dilbar kahe bagair"

Nauman said...

I am terribly sorry for my earlier message. All this was a huge misunderstanding. I know that artists are sensitive people. I am not an artist but still I am a bit sensitive or more properly egotistic. But you really know how to play with words. This is why you have to be sensitive by nature.

Khulta kissi pay kion meray dil ka muamila
Shairon kay intikhaab nay ruswa kiya mujhey
Ghalib.

#