Susan Boyle and the Bollywood Fantasy

She could not carry her act through. This too seems to be an act. I have already written about Susan Boyle and the comparison with the flogging video of the girl from Swat.

Now, we hear that she lost the Britain's Got Talent show to a hip-hop group, Diversity.

I did not expect her to win. The underdog has to remain one for a bit longer. That is what makes it charming and believable. We are in the business of 'make-believe', right?

Let me draw your attention to a similar Bollywood story. The angelic voice, a burnt face. We are talking about the protagonist in Raj Kapoor's Satyam Shivam Sundaram. It is supposed to mean "Truth is God and God is beautiful".

This is to further convey that beauty is not skin deep. However, the director chose an actress who was glamorous and sexy and willing to bare a lot of skin, but could not act.

As this poster clearly shows, it is her voluptuousness that is of value; you do not notice any blemish.

This completely negates the Boyle law that thrives on several blemishes. Zeenat Aman in the film pouts into the edge of her saree, pulls it with her lips to hide the scars. The hero falls in love with her, not merely her voice, but her form. Her attempts at revealing the truth do not fructify in the classic genre of taking the story forward.

When he finds out, he is aghast. He hates her. Then begins the pretence. The one with the voice and the one without.

The denouement is, of course, predictable. About truth and god and beauty. It is like the beatific expression of the woman who climaxes after long sessions of titillation. In several sequences in the film she is shown watering the Shiva Linga, the holy phallic symbol. There is ecstasy in her every move. It is almost a sexual act because most times she is drenched.

Susan Boyle uses her body and persona in a similar fashion. She represents the regular type, the Plain Jane in a fairytale. The woman who talks about her non-existent love life is as much open about it as one who flaunts it. It is drawing attention to possibilities.

Both are objects of desire in their own peculiar ways and spur male fantasies to save them from a life of tedium. And both are smart enough to work on those fantasies to embellish their own.


  1. FV,
    All around us there are images of the woman being shown as "picture perfect Greek goddess" and that has become a benchmark for media ...that benchmark changes a little bit every year cosmetically ....but what % of women fit that benchmark ....i guess less than 10% and that too for a small window in the prime of their life ...so when a seemingly "normal" woman is shown as doing better ....she becomes the "sorry" woman ....Why ???.....
    "Perfection" does not exist by nature ,mankind has built this illusionistic concept to create self pity and Industries (beauty products for one) .Women are pretty even with facial hair, double chins and stretch marks......

  2. Manish, agree with you on most points...

    Women are pretty even with facial hair, double chins and stretch marks......

    This sounds like A good malt speaking:)Jaago re...


Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.